Rebecca Rhynhart Considering Primary Challenge for Philly Controller

Rebecca_Rhynhart.jpg(Rebecca Rhynhart)

One good thing about politics as a hobby is that if one election doesn't go your way, the next one is always just six months away. And luckily for those Philadelphians who have an overabundance of nervous energy to burn after 2016, the two major citywide primaries in 2017, for District Attorney and Controller, are shaping up to be competitive elections where a little volunteer work could go a long way toward changing the course on important issues facing Philly.

We've been tuning into the District Attorney pre-primary action this fall, where incumbent D.A. Seth Williams has already attracted three primary opponents--former federal prosecutor Joe Khan, former Managing Director Rich Negrin, and Municipal Court judge Teresa Carr Deni--with more potentially in the offing.

Seth Williams has taken a beating in the media for most of the year as a result of several ethical and political missteps, and Democratic City Committee chair Bob Brady recently told City & State PA that the party might decline to endorse Williams for reelection, setting the stage for a competitive primary.

If too many candidates get in and split the opposition vote, the more the race favors Williams, but Philly voters are still in for a real campaign for their votes next year. Add in the backdrop of the 2017 police union contract negotiations, and the city has a rare opportunity for an extended debate about some of the law and justice issues that have been simmering in local politics in recent years. 

The DA race isn't the only citywide primary happening next year. The Controller is also on the ballot in 2017, but until recently it had looked like the incumbent, Alan Butkovitz, wouldn't attract a challenger. Now, Chris Brennan reports that the City's Chief Administrative Officer, Rebecca Rhynhart, is seriously considering a run.

Prior to her appointment as Chief Administrative Officer, a new position created by Mayor Jim Kenney, Rhynhart served for six years as Budget Director under Michael Nutter, after two years as City Treasurer. She also has relevant private sector experience, having worked for Bear Stearns and Fitch Ratings. 

Brennan raises the issue of whether someone coming from the Kenney administration could pivot to be a watchdog monitoring the Kenney administration, which is a question Rhynhart will need a good answer for if she gets in the race.

Still, Rhynhart has worked for Michael Nutter much longer than she's worked for Jim Kenney--two men who don't get along--and the more interesting political angle is that we could potentially have an ally of Michael Nutter overseeing the Kenney administration's fiscal activities. Alan Butkovitz says he hasn't had the same antagonistic relationship with Jim Kenney that he had with Michael Nutter, although it's still early in the Kenney administration.

The Mayor's office is also arguably not even the most pressing priority for the Controller's oversight, given the opportunities for reform at unaccountable but important agencies like the Philadelphia Parking Authority, the Sheriff's office real estate division, the Philadelphia Housing Authority, PHL International Airport, the Delaware River Port Authority, and more.

The Controller's office could be a real asset to government reformers if inclined to work with groups like Open Data Philly and Code for Philly to make the city budget more accessible and understandable to non-specialists, and there's no better occasion than a competitive primary to make the would-be inhabitants of that office refocus on what a 21st century Controller's office can do in the age of open data, and where it should go looking for poorly-spent funds.

Both of the 2017 citywide elections will address key issues that Philly will face under a Trump administration--how to keep communities safe while protecting everyone's rights, and how to maintain current services from a shrinking pot of federal and state money. The circumstances call for creative leadership on both counts, and the timing couldn't be better for a citywide conversation.

Sign up for our email newsletter and follow us on Facebook and Twitter to stay in the loop on the latest political news, events, and updates from Philadelphia 3.0

Showing 2 reactions

Please check your e-mail for a link to activate your account.
  • Michael Skiendzielewski
    commented 2017-04-24 09:31:53 -0400
    Rebecca Rhynhart endorsed??? Why did she fail to respond/act in her previous position as Chief Administrative Officer for the City of Philadelphia?

    When I requested her office, that of the Chief Administrative Officer of the City of Philadelphia, to investigate why the Tax Review Board (under her supervision) DOES NOT advise petitioners of the availability of the OPTION of another appeal under Article 15 of the TRB regulations, her office provided an empty, non-specific response. Though the TRB, under Executive Director Paula Weiss, does advise TRB petitioners of their right to appeal their case to the Court of Common Pleas (which costs money in terms of filing fees and attorney costs), the TRB and CAO refuses to advise petitioners, after the initial appeal is rejected, of their option to request another hearing from the TRB. According to information received by Paula Weiss, this Article 15 request for a rehearing is not a “guaranteed right” and if you are not notifying petitioners of its existence, I guess it is one of those “secret” rights.

    I wonder if Rebecca Rhynhart was/is aware of the fact that on occasion, the Executive Director, Paula Weiss, sometimes has secured the services of the Office of the Sheriff of the City of Philadelphia for certain, select hearings in front of the Tax Review Board?

    Michael Skiendzielewski
    Captain (retired)
    Philadelphia Police Dept.
  • Lisa Howdyshell
    commented 2016-12-16 12:58:12 -0500
    Since Rebecca is a current city employee, will she be required to leave her position with the city prior to campaigning?